Home > Forum > Broker'S/ Shipper'S/ Carrier'S

Broker's/ Shipper's/ Carrier's

Oct 30, 2023 at 07:50 AM CST
+ 11 - 1
Dear brokers, shippers, carriers, Please, if you don't know, there is a difference between an AG hopper and a commodities hopper trailer. It's the size of the doors. The bigger the door, the steeper the slopes. In other words, stop loading difficult commodities on ag hoppers. All you are doing is holding up everyone whom has the RIGHT equipment for the product being hauled. WAKE UP. I know I am not the only one who is sick and tired of being stuck at a feed mill or a pet food plant behind someone who loaded protein, or rice bran, etc. on an AG hopper that has been unloading for 3 hours, because it won't come off. Get it together people, buy the right equipment for the job, or get out of the way ! Rant over !
Replied on Mon, Oct 30, 2023 at 10:37 AM CST
5 hours and counting
Replied on Tue, Oct 31, 2023 at 06:56 AM CST
+ 2
Try showing up with a belt trailer with the ability to unload in 10 minutes only to sit all day behind a line of hoppers.... Yeah that's what it's like for me. I did unload DDG at a place on the Mississippi River this summer that had time limits. If you couldn't unload in a half hour you moved to the back of the line.
Replied on Tue, Oct 31, 2023 at 09:35 AM CST
+ 1
Could it be that the product hauled wasn't fully dried, facility has small pit, some plants can slow pit speed down to prevent plugging. Also some facility have tools ( platform ladders, air compressor, long air hoses. There's much a facility or driver can do for each other. Just saying.
Replied on Tue, Oct 31, 2023 at 09:42 AM CST
+ 1
As for as the belt trailer, I been wind-rowing product on a pad & have belt trailers back right in front of me and don't ask because they can unld in 10-15 min. Then again I've waved belt trailers around me knowing how much time certain products take to unld.
Replied on Tue, Oct 31, 2023 at 10:30 AM CST
+ 2
I agree Donald. But what I was trying to point out is that it has become commonplace for brokers, shippers and carriers to load products on ag hoppers, knowing full well that some of these products should never be loaded on an ag hopper. Period ! The fact is we have way to many people whom have no idea there is a difference in trailers. I myself have had to explain it several times at several locations. They all fight getting the load off and can't figure out why. But the hopper world has been flooded with ag hoppers and new hopper drivers whom are holding up the guys with the right equipment for the product being hauled. My opinion, brokers, and shippers should refuse to load ag hoppers with certain products. There has to be some common sense somewhere. These facilities end up paying detention time on trucks that are waiting, because 1 guy loaded meat and bone meal in an ag hopper. And took 5 hours to unload. The whole supply chain is screwed, because of people with no common sense. Bottom line, nobody cares.....just load it on whomever shows up, and screw the guys waiting at the other end for some jack@$$ who loaded an ag hopper
Replied on Tue, Oct 31, 2023 at 03:04 PM CST
+ 2

I've hauled both types of trailers and depending on the product they're both hard on load depending on the product it's not the trailer it's the equipment you have to get it unloaded not the trailer belt trailers do have an easier time than any hopper bottom but with commodity hoppers if you're out at a farm unloading pellets or whatever You're too low to the ground for their augers but yet you still go there so don't miss speak we're all here to make a buck if somebody's having trouble unloading it's usually not the trailer it's the person that's doing it or the product think before you spout it's not always based on the trailer my rants over

Replied on Wed, Nov 01, 2023 at 07:08 AM CST
+ 1
I don't have any hoppers. I have belts and floors. I understand the hold up. If it's someone that does it more than once shame on him. However people have to have an opportunity to learn.
Replied on Wed, Nov 01, 2023 at 07:09 AM CST
Yes sirs, I fully agree with what both are saying. Yes it's true, a broker will put ld on the wrong type of trailer knowing full well he's not the one who has delivery it or deal with the fallout behind it. I've delivered to a farm that only used end dumps. I called customer gave them a heads up and simply bcuz they needed feed. Customer said they're not set up for hopper, but they're going to unld and advise me that it's going to a long day. No detention for being there for hrs. Ask broker for detention and his answers was no. So we parted ways. Yet he still calls.
Replied on Thu, Nov 02, 2023 at 06:56 AM CST
+ 1

Man I just bought a hopper 43x96x79 with ag hopper, is that going to be a big problem? I thought it would be better at the the mom and pops that we deliver to that has the slide under belt and ramp, I don't want to have to fight someone like his guy when he sees my trailer unloading at some places and blames the wait on me? Can someone chime in with some encouragement or do I need to try to find another trailer?

Replied on Thu, Nov 02, 2023 at 01:25 PM CST
1st 1st served
Replied on Thu, Nov 02, 2023 at 01:46 PM CST
Jeff - ag hoppers doesn't necessarily mean small doors. Ag hopper is 24" ground clearance, I have an ag hopper with commodity doors on it - not super common, but they are out there.
Replied on Fri, Nov 03, 2023 at 07:00 AM CST

if the truck gets the job done and its the only truck available the truck is gonna get used

Replied on Fri, Nov 03, 2023 at 07:00 AM CST

I got the big doors just 21" off the ground

Replied on Sat, Nov 04, 2023 at 09:34 AM CST
My understanding is a ag hopper has higher clearance off the ground. I own (10) 2022 commodities hoppers Wilson Commanders and (2) 2024 ag Hoppers Wilson Commanders. Only difference in my trailers is the Ag hoppers are higher off the ground which allows my drivers to hopefully not rip a door off going into a barn or across a set of tracks, etc.
Replied on Sat, Nov 04, 2023 at 09:34 AM CST
- 1

I guess with the ONE DISLIKE, you must have got someone's panties in a wad. That's probably the same persone who parks in the fuel island so no one else can get fuel until they have taken their 30 minute break, got something to eat, used the bathroom, and thoroughly wasted everyone elses time.🤷🤯

Replied on Sun, Nov 05, 2023 at 07:59 PM CST
- 1
Quote: "I guess with the ONE DISLIKE, you must have got someone's panties in a wad. That's probably the same persone who parks in the fuel island so no one else can get fuel until they have taken their 30 minute break, got something to eat, used the bathroom, and thoroughly wasted everyone elses time.🤷🤯 "

Or a broker who gets their panties in a wad when you won't take their load at $1.75 a mile😎 Come on with your dislike, I know it's coming🤷🤦‍♂️

Replied on Sun, Nov 05, 2023 at 07:59 PM CST
+ 1
By reading some of the replies, it's obvious what I said. Some guys just don't know. The bigger the doors, the steeper the slopes ! Plus the load is being carried with a lower center of gravity. With 24.5 tires, mine is 18" at the lowest point of the doors. Which is the bearing housings for doors. I have never NOT been able to unload due to a clearance issue. A pan auger goes under with no problem. The point was we have entirely to many guys whom have drifted over into hauling proteins and other commodities that have ag hoppers. Which is not and was never designed to haul anything but grain. Those of you that claim you have big doors, are you sure ? Because I just had a discussion with a guy in Denver that couldn't get the load off, I said it's because you're using an ag hopper. Thus the argument. I could clearly and plainly see his doors wide open, and the height of the doors. He said " this isn't an ag hopper " he is either blind or ignorant. Or someone sold him a trailer claiming big doors, and he doesn't know the difference. Like I said, people just don't know. Until they see me unload the same product, and roll the doors wide open and the product wants to come off. It was a simple post about what I experience every week. What I see. My opinion is, it needs to stop.
Replied on Mon, Nov 06, 2023 at 07:20 AM CST
I will make it simple. Just stop using ag hoppers ! It's really that simple. You need an ag hopper for the farm, buy one and keep it on the farm. You buy an ag hopper and want to haul grain, have at it. But don't come out here with the wrong equipment, plugging up the feed mills and pet food plants. I am not the only one your poor decisions are affecting. There are plenty of other drivers/ owners on here that see the same thing. Why is it so hard to understand ?
Replied on Mon, Nov 06, 2023 at 10:34 AM CST
+ 1 - 1
Quote: "I will make it simple. Just stop using ag hoppers ! It's really that simple. You need an ag hopper for the farm, buy one and keep it on the farm. You buy an ag hopper and want to haul grain, have at it. But don't come out here with the wrong equipment, plugging up the feed mills and pet food plants. I am not the only one your poor decisions are affecting. There are plenty of other drivers/ owners on here that see the same thing. Why is it so hard to understand ?"

It's interesting reading the comments here between hopper carriers. In my opinion A) If it takes longer than a half hour to unload because product doesn't flow, you showed up with the wrong equipment. B) If it takes beating the side of your equipment like it owes you money in order to get product to flow, you showed up with the wrong equipment. C) If you have to wind-row product because the receiver of that product doesn't have a pit or auger, you showed up with the wrong equipment.... When I first started with commodity hauling it only took one load of sticky DDG to cure me of ever wanting to haul commodities in a hopper. If you want to haul sticky commodities, do it with a belt, walking floor, or end dump.

Replied on Mon, Nov 06, 2023 at 11:31 AM CST
Yessir, I have gotten out of line a few times and I've asked drivers behind me to go ahead if they have ez products. But it's only been a few times. I'll say this, if I've started a difficult product (ddg, bakery meal, rice bran) if a guy or guys want to help out. I'm grateful for that too.
Replied on Mon, Nov 06, 2023 at 11:40 AM CST
+ 2

Patrick,

While your irritation is understandable, I am not sure your understanding of hopper specifications is entirely accurate.

When you go to spec out new trailers depending on the company the possibilities are endless. I currently spec all my trailers with an "ag hopper" clearance since my seed customers require 22 inches of clearance under the traps, and they will measure it. I have a maximum side height of 84 inches to maximize capacity while still being able to fit under a grain vac for farm loading of organic products. I run 102 wide trailers for the additional capacity for hauling Midds and Loose soy hulls for our feed customers. I run a trap opening of 36 inches by 54 which is larger than most other manufacturers. Fainally I run a 42 foot 11 inch length for pet food plants that require less than 43 feet. I run cornhusker trailers because they worked with me to customize this specification for my operation.

I also run some "traditional" ag hoppers in the standard 40-foot long 96 wide 66-inch side wall. These trailers are Prestige brand and feature a tiny 24 x 24 trap opening which works amazing for swing hoppers and delivering to fertilizer locations. However, these trailers offer a minimum of 33-degree slope, which is the same as a Timpte commodity hopper. Some drivers prefer hauling SBM in these trailers because they empty and clean out so easily even with the small doors.

In our experience the cleanliness of the slope sheets and the care given to keep them smooth play a bigger role in if a load will come out than any other factor. That and the size and placement of Vibrators. Take note Jeff, you will be fine, just pay attention to the details.

I agree that if a person or company plans on hauling commodities they should make sure their equipment is up to the task. However, hopper clearance and door size do not play as big a role in my experience as slope cleanliness and product consistency. I could certainly be wrong, my position is coming from doing the ordering of new trailers, having 28 hoppers in the fleet, and hauling most of the products myself.

Rob

Replied on Tue, Nov 07, 2023 at 04:28 PM CST
Quote: "It's interesting reading the comments here between hopper carriers. In my opinion A) If it takes longer than a half hour to unload because product doesn't flow, you showed up with the wrong equipment. B) If it takes beating the side of your equipment like it owes you money in order to get product to flow, you showed up with the wrong equipment. C) If you have to wind-row product because the receiver of that product doesn't have a pit or auger, you showed up with the wrong equipment.... When I first started with commodity hauling it only took one load of sticky DDG to cure me of ever wanting to haul commodities in a hopper. If you want to haul sticky commodities, do it with a belt, walking floor, or end dump. "

I hauled midds everyday for 2 years and we had to beat on the trailers to get them to flow. Did we have the wrong equipment? No, we had 96"x102'X50' 3 tub triple Timpte trailers with 56" or 64" traps. Some commodities just don't flow easily, no matter what trailer you have and sometimes it takes time to unload. I mean no disrespect, but we are all out here trying to make a living. Rather than be at each other's throats, how about we try to help and educate each other? I have been in the trucking industry since 1987 and can state for a fact that I learn something new every day OR help someone with the knowledge I have aquired by the grace of God.

Keith, ET Trucking Inc.

Replied on Wed, Nov 08, 2023 at 07:04 AM CST
Quote: "I hauled midds everyday for 2 years and we had to beat on the trailers to get them to flow. Did we have the wrong equipment? No, we had 96"x102'X50' 3 tub triple Timpte trailers with 56" or 64" traps. Some commodities just don't flow easily, no matter what trailer you have and sometimes it takes time to unload. I mean no disrespect, but we are all out here trying to make a living. Rather than be at each other's throats, how about we try to help and educate each other? I have been in the trucking industry since 1987 and can state for a fact that I learn something new every day OR help someone with the knowledge I have aquired by the grace of God. Keith, ET Trucking Inc."

Excellent post Keith! I wouldn't consider wheat midds to be a sticky product, just bulky. A high sided hopper is just right for midds. What I'm referring to is products like DDG, hominy feed, beet shreds, and cottonseed. Those products usually pay a small premium for equipment that is self unloading, but the hopper guys seem bound and determined to make those products work in order to get that premium. For example, I used to haul a lot of beet shreds to a large receiver who had a barn for storage, but didn't have a pit or auger for a hopper to unload in. The loads paid well and were originally being run by belt and walking floor carriers, but when they couldn't find enough belt and walking floor carriers they started contacting hopper carriers. Once the hoppers started showing up the rates fell, and the time to unload increased. One day I asked one of the hopper guys if the broker told him the product was hard to unload and that he would have to wind-row it? He said "yeah the broker told me, but the load pays well enough that it doesn't matter"...... I hope he enjoyed the couple hours it took to unload... It's like that a lot, hence my frustration.

Replied on Wed, Nov 15, 2023 at 10:50 AM CST
Robert Grover, you missed the whole point. My statement was about guys whom have recently decided to pull a hopper, whom haven't done it before. Guys whom have come over from different industry because it was slow. This isn't and wasn't about owner operator's whom have been doing it for years specking out a new trailer. That isn't the problem I was talking about. But I am glad you were able to use the forum to toot your own horn and yet have no understanding